Free Shipping on Orders $75+

Make gifting easy with our gift registry!

Start your registry
Crazy Aaron's BIG Better Butter Thinking Putty BIG Tin

Crazy Aaron's BIG Better Butter Thinking Putty - BIG Tin

$39.99
by ACDD

Pickup available at Little Lincoln's Toy Shop - Springfield

Usually ready in 24 hours

View store information

Shipping Info

You can expect your order to be shipped out within 1 to 2 business days (unless it's a holiday or the weekend). And guess what? If your order is worth more than $75.00, congratulations! You've just unlocked free shipping! But don't fret if your total is $74.99 or less; we're still happy to ship it for a flat rate of $7.95. For more info, check out our shipping and delivery page!

Order by 12/15/25 for expected delivery by 12/24/25!

Gift Wrap Available

Want to add some pizzazz to your purchase? Opt for our free gift-wrapping service! It's like a little bonus present for yourself (or someone else, we don't judge). Just let us know your gift instructions on the shopping cart page.

Pickup Hours & Location

We are now located at 3001 West White Oaks Drive in Springfield.

HOLIDAY HOURS:
Easter Sunday - Closed

Memorial Day - Closed

4th of July - Closed

Labor Day - Closed

Pickup Hours

Monday-Friday 10AM to 6PM

Saturday 10AM to 5PM

Sunday 12PM to 4PM

A little butter, a lot of play! Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty fills this oversized tin with bright yellow putty that's wonderfully creamy and smooth. Stretch it, squeeze it, twist it, or spread it out—then gather it up and start again. It's a satisfying pick for kids and grown-ups who love keeping their hands busy, with plenty of putty for bigger creations and screen-free play.

Why We Love It

  • Buttery-smooth texture makes every stretch and squeeze feel extra satisfying.
  • The oversized tin gives putty fans more to knead, mold, and explore.
  • Simple, open-ended sensory play invites creativity without instructions or a screen.
  • Never dries out, so it's ready for another round of play.

Good to Know

  • Includes one BIG tin of yellow Better Butter Thinking Putty.
  • Age recommendation: 3+
  • Non-toxic; not edible.
  • Battery requirements: none
  • Made in the USA.