Free Shipping on Orders $75+
2026 Summer Toy Guide is Here! Shop Now
Best toys for 4 year olds and creative birthday gifts at Little Lincoln’s Toy Shop in Springfield IL

Ages 4-5

Filter by
Sort by Best Selling
Sort by

175 products

Image of Beanie Bouncers Everest
Quick buy
Beanie Bouncers
Ty
$6.99
Quick buy
Construction Utensils
Constructive Eating
$6.95
Coco Village Zylo Large Elephant Animal Play Figurine - toy animal figure at Little Lincoln's Toy Shop in Springfield IL
Quick buy
Zylo Animals Large
CocoVillage
$9.99
Image of Dinosaur Escape Game packaging
Quick buy
Dinosaur Escape
Peaceable Kingdom
$22.99
Hoot Owl Hoot! Board Game packaging
Quick buy
Hoot Owl Hoot!
Peaceable Kingdom
$19.99
Image of Whirly Squigz
Quick buy
Whirly Squigz
Fat Brain Toys
$27.99
Box of Rail Cube Magnetic Monorail Deluxe Block Set on a white background
Quick buy
Rail Cube Magnetic Monorail Deluxe Block Set
Meekins Corp
$199.99
Image of Magna-Tiles MicroMags Travel Set packaging
Quick buy
Magna-Tiles MicroMags Travel Set
Magna-Tiles
$19.99
Image of Dinosaurs Stamp Set
Quick buy
Dinosaurs Stamp Set
Melissa & Doug
$16.99
Image of Bubble Blowing Whale
Quick buy
Bubble Blowing Whale
Hape
$12.99
Model of a camper van with accessories on a white background
Quick buy
Dickie Toys Pop Up Camper Playset
Toysmith
$34.99 Sold Out
Image of Where’s Squeaky?
Quick buy
Where’s Squeaky?
Blue Orange
$21.99
Image of SmartMax Start 23 Pc Set
Quick buy
SmartMax Start 23 Pc Set
Smart Toys and Games
$49.99
Toy truck set packaging with four yellow trucks and a remote control, featuring the Kidoozie brand.
Quick buy
Kidoozie Tool Time Truck Set
Epoch
$29.99 Sold Out
Quick buy
Boogie Board Sketch Pals
Boogie Board
$22.99
Image of 10 Jumbo Triangular Crayons in packaging
Quick buy
10 Jumbo Triangular Crayons
Melissa & Doug
$7.99
Plush toy horse with a stick on a white background
Quick buy
ThinAir Brands Stick Pony
ThinAir Brands
$34.99
Image of Tractor Fork and Tractor Spoon
Quick buy
Green Tractor Utensils
Constructive Eating
$12.99
Image of Horn Brightz Blue
Quick buy
Horn Brightz Blue
Brightz, Ltd.
$14.99
Image of AirFort - UFO
Quick buy
AirFort - UFO
AirFort
$64.99
Image of Color Blast! - Dinosaur
Quick buy
Color Blast! - Dinosaur
Melissa & Doug
$7.99 Sold Out
Wooden Slice & Play Fruit Crate from Jasey's Toy Chest at Little Lincoln's Toy Shop in Springfield IL
Quick buy
Wooden Slice & Play Fruit Crate
Jasey's Toy Chest
$19.99
BRIO Forklift toy for kids ages 3+.
Quick buy
BRIO Forklift
BRIO
$22.99
Quick buy
Rainbow Fart Plush
Bewaltz
$16.99
Quick buy
Rail Cube Magnetic Monorail Starter Block Set
Meekins Corp
$99.99
Image of ZINGO game packaging
Quick buy
ZINGO!
Thinkfun
$24.99
Image of Foil Fun Unicorns and Princesses
Quick buy
Foil Fun Unicorns and Princesses
Skillmatics
$19.99
Image of Counting Songs - Tonie
Quick buy
Counting Songs - Tonie
Tonies
$19.99
Image of Water Wow! Space
Quick buy
Water Wow! Space
Melissa & Doug
$7.99
Image of Butterfly Tea Set by Melissa & Doug in packaging
Quick buy
Bella Butterfly Tea Set
Melissa & Doug
$34.99
Hape Unicorn Friends Puzzle in wooden tray with colorful unicorn scene
Quick buy
Unicorn Friends Puzzle
Hape
$12.99
Image of Melissa & Doug Let's Explore Campfire S'mores Play Set
Quick buy
Let's Explore Campfire S'mores Play Set
Melissa & Doug
$29.99